Is The Church Of Latter Day Saints Truly Christian?

There has been a long-standing debate over whether the Church of Latter Day Saints, commonly known as the LDS or Mormon Church, is truly a Christian denomination. Despite having millions of members worldwide, the LDS Church has faced criticism and skepticism from some Christian groups over its beliefs, practices, and origins.

In this article, we will delve deeper into the controversy and attempt to answer the question: is the Church of Latter Day Saints truly Christian? To do so, we will first define the meaning of Christianity and explore how the LDS Church aligns with this definition.

Next, we will examine the origins and unique beliefs and practices of the LDS Church and discuss the controversies that have surrounded the Church in recent years. Finally, we will conclude with an analysis of the opinions of mainstream Christianity on the Church of Latter Day Saints.

Read on to learn more about this controversial topic and discover the truth behind the question of whether the LDS Church is a Christian denomination.

Defining Christianity and The Church Of Latter Day Saints

Before we can determine whether The Church of Latter Day Saints (LDS) is truly Christian, we need to establish a clear definition of what Christianity is. According to the Bible, Christianity is based on the belief that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, that he died for our sins, and that through him, we can achieve salvation and eternal life.

LDS, on the other hand, is a relatively new religion founded in the early 19th century by Joseph Smith. According to its teachings, an angel appeared to Joseph Smith and revealed a new set of scriptures, known as the Book of Mormon. While the Book of Mormon is an important part of LDS teachings, it is not recognized as scripture by mainstream Christian denominations.

Despite the significant differences in belief, the LDS Church considers itself to be a Christian denomination. They believe that they are restoring the true Christian church, which was lost after the death of Jesus Christ’s original apostles. This claim is based on their belief in a Great Apostasy, where the true teachings of Christ were lost and corrupted over time.

However, many Christian denominations do not recognize the LDS Church as a Christian denomination, citing the significant differences in belief and practices. This has led to significant debates and controversies surrounding whether or not the LDS Church is truly Christian.

The Core Beliefs of Christianity

1. Belief in the Trinity: The most fundamental belief of Christianity is the belief in one God, consisting of three distinct persons: the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. This concept of the Trinity is the cornerstone of Christian theology.

2. Salvation through Faith: Christians believe that salvation is a gift from God and is received through faith in Jesus Christ. This means that individuals cannot earn salvation through good works or deeds, but must accept it as a free gift.

3. Resurrection of Jesus Christ: Christianity teaches that Jesus Christ was crucified, died, and was buried, but on the third day, He rose from the dead. This event is considered the cornerstone of the Christian faith and is celebrated on Easter Sunday.

These core beliefs form the foundation of Christianity and are shared by most Christian denominations. However, the Church of Latter Day Saints, also known as the Mormon Church, has some significant differences in their beliefs that have caused controversy within the Christian community.

The Doctrines of The Church of Latter Day Saints

• Restorationism: The Church of Latter Day Saints believes that the true church established by Jesus Christ was lost over time and needed to be restored.

• Continuing Revelation: The church believes in continuing revelation, meaning that God can and does communicate with humanity beyond the Bible.

• Pre-Mortal Existence: The church believes that all humans existed as spirits before being born on earth and that individuals had the opportunity to choose to follow God or Satan in a pre-mortal existence.

These unique beliefs, among others, have led some to question whether the Church of Latter Day Saints is truly Christian. However, the church’s emphasis on Jesus Christ as the Son of God and the belief in the Bible as scripture demonstrate its commitment to Christian principles.

Comparing the Two Religions

There are many similarities and differences between Christianity and The Church of Latter Day Saints, and these can help us understand the controversy over whether or not the latter is truly Christian. One of the most notable differences is the approach to scripture. Christianity typically relies on the Bible as the primary source of religious authority, while The Church of Latter Day Saints also recognizes The Book of Mormon and other texts as holy scripture.

Another difference is the belief in the nature of God. Christianity holds that God is a Trinity, consisting of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, while The Church of Latter Day Saints teaches that God the Father, Jesus Christ, and the Holy Ghost are three distinct beings with separate roles in the Godhead.

Additionally, The Church of Latter Day Saints has a unique understanding of the afterlife. While Christianity teaches that the soul is immortal and will either go to heaven or hell, The Church of Latter Day Saints believes in a tiered afterlife with multiple degrees of glory. This includes the possibility of exaltation and becoming a god or goddess in the afterlife.

Despite these differences, there are also many similarities between the two religions. Both emphasize the importance of faith, repentance, and following the teachings of Jesus Christ. Both also believe in the atonement and resurrection of Jesus Christ as central to their theology. Ultimately, while there are differences in doctrine and practice, it is up to individual interpretation to determine whether or not The Church of Latter Day Saints is truly Christian.

The Origins of The Church Of Latter Day Saints

Joseph Smith: The founder of The Church Of Latter Day Saints, Joseph Smith, claimed to have received a revelation from God in the early 19th century.

The Book of Mormon: According to Smith, he was instructed to translate and publish an ancient text, which became known as The Book of Mormon, another testament of Jesus Christ.

The Church is Established: In 1830, Smith established The Church Of Latter Day Saints in Fayette, New York, and gained a small following.

Migration West: The church faced persecution and violence in New York and Ohio, so Smith led his followers on a westward migration, eventually settling in Nauvoo, Illinois.

Death of Joseph Smith: Smith’s leadership and controversial practices led to his arrest and eventual murder by a mob in 1844, leading to a leadership crisis within the church.

Joseph Smith and the First Vision

Joseph Smith, the founder of The Church of Latter Day Saints, claimed to have had a profound religious experience in his youth. This experience, known as the First Vision, occurred in the early 1820s, when Joseph was just 14 years old. According to his account, he saw God the Father and Jesus Christ appear to him in a vision.

The First Vision is considered to be a pivotal moment in the history of The Church of Latter Day Saints, as it served as the catalyst for Joseph Smith’s prophetic calling and the subsequent founding of the church.

Some critics of The Church of Latter Day Saints have challenged the authenticity of the First Vision, pointing to discrepancies between Joseph Smith’s various accounts of the experience.

The Book of Mormon and Other Scriptures

The Book of Mormon is considered by members of The Church of Latter Day Saints to be another testament of Jesus Christ. According to the church, it was written by ancient prophets who lived in the Americas and is a companion to the Bible.

In addition to the Book of Mormon, members of the church also accept other scriptures, such as the Doctrine and Covenants and the Pearl of Great Price. These texts contain revelations given to Joseph Smith and other leaders of the church.

The church’s interpretation of these scriptures differs from traditional Christian interpretations, and some of its teachings are considered controversial by other Christian denominations. For example, the Doctrine and Covenants teaches that marriage can continue beyond death, and that individuals can be baptized on behalf of deceased ancestors.

Members of The Church of Latter Day Saints believe that the Book of Mormon and other scriptures are divinely inspired and provide guidance for daily living. The church places a strong emphasis on the importance of personal revelation and encourages its members to seek guidance from God through prayer and other spiritual practices.

However, critics of the church argue that its emphasis on these additional scriptures, as well as the teachings and practices that differ from traditional Christianity, are evidence that it is not a truly Christian denomination.

Unique Beliefs and Practices of The Church Of Latter Day Saints

Temple Ordinances: One unique practice of the Church of Latter Day Saints is their belief in temple ordinances, including baptisms for the dead, eternal marriage, and sealing families together. These ordinances are considered essential for salvation and can only be performed in LDS temples.

Word of Wisdom: The Church of Latter Day Saints has a health code known as the Word of Wisdom. This code prohibits the consumption of alcohol, tobacco, coffee, tea, and other harmful substances. The church believes that following the Word of Wisdom will improve physical health and spiritual well-being.

Continuing Revelation: The LDS Church believes in continuing revelation, meaning that God can still communicate with His people today. This belief has led to new scriptures and teachings beyond the Bible and Book of Mormon.

Genealogy and Family History: The LDS Church places a strong emphasis on genealogy and family history. They believe that families can be sealed together for eternity, which motivates members to research and connect with their ancestors.

Missionary Work: The Church of Latter Day Saints is well-known for its missionary program, which encourages young men and women to share their faith with others around the world. Missionaries often serve for two years in a foreign country, learning a new language and culture while teaching others about their religion.

Baptism for the Dead

Baptism for the Dead is a unique practice of The Church of Latter Day Saints that involves living members of the church being baptized on behalf of deceased ancestors who did not have the opportunity to receive the ordinance during their lifetime.

This practice is based on the belief that those who have passed on still have the ability to accept or reject the gospel and that baptism is necessary for salvation.

Members of the church can trace their family history to find ancestors who have not received baptism and can then perform the ordinance on their behalf. This practice is not forced on anyone, and the church respects the religious freedom of all individuals, living or dead.

Controversies Surrounding The Church Of Latter Day Saints

The Church of Latter Day Saints has been the subject of controversy since its inception. Here are some of the controversies that have arisen over the years:

Polygamy: One of the most controversial aspects of the early Church was the practice of polygamy. Although the Church officially ended the practice in 1890, some breakaway groups still practice it today.

Racism: The Church has also been criticized for its past policies regarding race. Until 1978, Black people were not allowed to hold the priesthood or participate in some of the Church’s sacred ordinances.

Gender Issues: Another controversial issue is the role of women in the Church. Women are not allowed to hold the priesthood or serve in certain leadership positions, which has led to criticism from some members and outsiders.

Secrecy: Some people have also criticized the Church for its perceived secrecy and lack of transparency. The Church has been accused of hiding its financial records and being less than forthcoming about its history and beliefs.

Despite these controversies, the Church of Latter Day Saints continues to grow and thrive, with millions of members worldwide.

Polygamy and Early Church History

Polygamy, the practice of having multiple spouses, has been a controversial issue in the history of The Church of Latter Day Saints. The founder, Joseph Smith, was a polygamist and taught that it was necessary for exaltation in the afterlife. However, the practice was officially discontinued in 1890 as a condition for Utah’s statehood.

Early Church History is also fraught with controversy, including conflicts with non-Mormon settlers in Missouri and Illinois, culminating in the murder of Joseph Smith in 184The Church faced persecution and violence, which led to a mass migration to the Salt Lake Valley in Utah.

Despite the controversy surrounding these issues, The Church of Latter Day Saints has continued to grow and spread throughout the world, with a focus on families, missionary work, and serving others.

Racism and Discrimination

The Church of Latter Day Saints has had a complicated history with regards to race and discrimination. For much of its early history, the church was exclusively white, and many church leaders and members held racist beliefs.

Black individuals were not allowed to hold the priesthood or participate in temple ceremonies until 1978, when church president Spencer W. Kimball received a revelation that extended priesthood and temple blessings to all worthy members, regardless of race.

Despite this revelation, some Black members of the church have reported experiencing discrimination within the church, including microaggressions, overt racism, and lack of representation in leadership positions. The church has made efforts to address these issues and promote inclusivity and diversity, but there is still progress to be made.

There have also been controversies surrounding the church’s past teachings on race and the origins of different races, which some have criticized as promoting racist beliefs. The church has since disavowed these teachings and issued statements condemning racism and bigotry in all forms.

Allegations of Financial Misconduct

Background: The Church of Latter Day Saints is known for its vast financial resources and business holdings. The church is estimated to be worth billions of dollars.

Allegations: Despite its wealth, the church has faced allegations of financial misconduct, including misusing tithes and donations for non-charitable purposes. In 2019, a whistleblower alleged that the church had a $100 billion investment portfolio that was not being used for charitable purposes as required by law.

Response: The church has denied any wrongdoing and stated that its financial practices are in accordance with the law. However, the allegations have raised questions about the transparency of the church’s finances and its use of donations.

Investigation: In response to the allegations, the IRS has launched an investigation into the church’s tax-exempt status. The investigation is ongoing, and it is unclear what the outcome will be.

Opinions of Mainstream Christianity on The Church Of Latter Day Saints

Mainstream Christianity has had mixed opinions on The Church of Latter Day Saints, also known as the Mormon Church. Some view it as a non-Christian cult with heretical beliefs, while others see it as a legitimate Christian denomination with different theological views.

One of the main points of contention is the belief in additional scripture, including the Book of Mormon, which many mainstream Christians reject as not being divinely inspired.

There is also disagreement over the concept of “eternal progression,” which suggests that humans have the potential to become like God. Some Christian critics see this as a violation of the fundamental doctrine of the Trinity and a rejection of the uniqueness of Jesus Christ.

Despite these theological differences, some Christians have praised the Mormon Church’s emphasis on family values and charitable work, while others have criticized the church’s controversial historical practices, such as polygamy.

Overall, while there may be disagreements between mainstream Christianity and The Church of Latter Day Saints, it is important to engage in respectful dialogue and understand the differences and similarities between the two religions.

Evangelical Christians and the LDS Church

Evangelical Christians, who make up a significant portion of the Christian population in the United States, have been highly critical of the teachings and practices of the LDS Church. They often view the LDS Church as a cult and do not consider it to be a part of orthodox Christianity.

One of the main points of contention between Evangelical Christians and the LDS Church is the belief in the Book of Mormon, which Evangelicals reject as a non-biblical text. Evangelicals also reject the LDS belief in continuing revelation and the authority of the Prophet and apostles.

Another area of concern for Evangelicals is the LDS Church’s emphasis on works-based salvation, which they believe contradicts the biblical doctrine of salvation by grace through faith alone. Evangelicals also criticize the LDS Church’s practice of baptizing deceased ancestors and their belief in a three-tiered heaven.

Despite these differences, some Evangelicals have sought to engage in dialogue with members of the LDS Church in an effort to better understand their beliefs and promote mutual respect. Others, however, maintain a firm stance against the LDS Church and view it as a threat to the purity of Christianity.

Conclusion: Is The Church Of Latter Day Saints Christian?

Despite the controversies and unique beliefs and practices of The Church of Latter Day Saints, the answer to whether or not they are Christian is not straightforward. While they believe in Jesus Christ and the Bible, they also have additional scriptures and teachings that some Christian denominations do not accept.

Some Christian denominations and individuals may view the LDS Church as non-Christian or a cult, while others may recognize them as a distinct Christian denomination with their own unique beliefs and practices.

Ultimately, whether or not the LDS Church is considered Christian is a matter of personal opinion and interpretation. It is up to individuals and Christian denominations to decide whether or not they accept the LDS Church as part of the Christian faith.

Regardless of one’s personal beliefs, it is important to approach discussions and interactions with members of the LDS Church with respect and understanding of their beliefs and practices.

The LDS Church’s Claim to Christianity

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) considers itself a Christian denomination, but some Christian groups do not accept this claim. One reason for this is that the LDS church has different beliefs and practices than traditional Christian churches. For example, LDS doctrine teaches that God and Jesus Christ are separate and distinct beings, while traditional Christian doctrine teaches that they are one.

Despite these differences, the LDS church asserts that it is a Christian church because it believes in Jesus Christ as the Son of God and the Savior of the world. The church teaches that Jesus Christ is the center of its doctrine and that its purpose is to help people come unto Him.

The LDS church also claims that it is part of the restoration of the original Christian church that Jesus Christ established during His mortal ministry. According to LDS doctrine, this restoration was necessary because the true gospel of Jesus Christ was lost or corrupted over time.

While the LDS church’s claim to Christianity may be disputed by some Christian groups, the church’s members consider themselves to be followers of Jesus Christ and strive to live according to His teachings.

Mainstream Christianity’s Perspective

Mainstream Christianity, including Protestantism and Catholicism, generally does not consider the Church of Latter Day Saints to be part of traditional Christianity. The reason for this is the significant differences in theology, doctrine, and practices between the two groups.

From the perspective of mainstream Christianity, the LDS Church’s belief in modern-day revelation, the Book of Mormon as scripture, and additional writings like the Doctrine and Covenants and Pearl of Great Price, are not considered part of the Christian canon.

Mainstream Christianity also does not recognize the LDS Church’s authority to baptize individuals on behalf of the dead, the belief in a pre-mortal existence, or the concept of eternal progression as compatible with traditional Christian beliefs.

While there are similarities between the two groups, such as a belief in Jesus Christ as the Son of God and a desire to follow his teachings, the differences are significant enough for mainstream Christianity to classify the LDS Church as a separate religious movement from traditional Christianity.

The Ongoing Debate

Despite the arguments put forth by both sides, the debate over whether The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is Christian continues. Those who believe that the LDS Church is not Christian cite theological differences and beliefs that differ from traditional Christian doctrine. Those who argue that the LDS Church is Christian point to the church’s belief in Jesus Christ as the Savior and the centrality of his teachings in their faith.

It is worth noting that the debate is not limited to theological differences but has also been fueled by political and cultural factors. Some conservative Christian groups have actively worked to oppose the LDS Church, while others have sought to build bridges and promote dialogue.

Despite the ongoing debate, it is ultimately up to individual Christians to determine whether they view the LDS Church as part of their faith tradition. While theological differences may be significant, many Christians find common ground in the belief in Jesus Christ and the importance of living a life of service and compassion.

Ultimately, it is important to approach the debate with an open mind and a willingness to engage in constructive dialogue. It is through respectful conversation and learning from one another that we can work towards greater understanding and unity in our diverse religious landscape.

Frequently Asked Questions